Why Does Your Brain Sabotage Your Savings? The Psychology Behind Investing and Spending

The Psychology Behind Investing and Spending | Mind Over Money
Mind & Money

The Psychology Behind Investing and Spending

Why your brain was never designed to make good financial decisions — and what you can actually do about it.

Updated February 2025  ·  7 min read  ·  For Indian Readers

You skip your morning chai to save ₹30. Then you spend ₹3,000 on a pair of earphones you didn’t need — just because they were “on sale.” Sound familiar? Welcome to the beautifully irrational world of financial psychology.

Most of us were taught that money is math. Spend less than you earn. Invest early. Diversify. Simple, right? Except almost nobody follows through. And the reason isn’t laziness or ignorance. It’s your brain.

The psychology behind investing and spending is a field that sits right at the intersection of economics and human behaviour. Nobel Prize-winning economists like Daniel Kahneman have spent decades proving one thing — humans are not rational with money. We are emotional, impulsive, and wonderfully predictable in our irrationality.

Let’s unpack why we make the financial decisions we do — and how understanding this can actually make you wealthier.


Why Your Brain Is a Bad Financial Advisor

Here’s a fun fact: your brain is essentially running on software written 200,000 years ago. Back then, survival meant eating the food in front of you now — not saving it for next winter. That instinct? It’s still running in the background every time you swipe your credit card.

Behavioural economists call this present bias — our tendency to prefer immediate rewards over future benefits. According to research published in the Journal of Behavioural Decision Making, people consistently overvalue what they can enjoy today by a factor of 3 to 5 times compared to an equivalent future benefit.

That’s why your SIP (Systematic Investment Plan) feels painful, but a weekend trip to Goa feels like an obvious choice.

Quick Insight

Present bias is also why the “save first, spend later” rule actually works. When your employer or app auto-deducts your investment before you see your salary, your brain never registers it as a “loss.” Out of sight, out of spending reach.


The Cognitive Biases That Cost Indians Crores Every Year

Cognitive biases are mental shortcuts your brain uses to make quick decisions. They’re useful in emergencies. They’re disasters in markets.

  • Loss Aversion: Kahneman and Tversky’s research showed that losing ₹500 feels roughly twice as painful as gaining ₹500 feels good. This is why investors panic-sell during market dips — even when holding would clearly be the smarter move.
  • Herd Mentality: Everyone bought crypto in 2021. Everyone bought Adani stocks on rumours. Herd behaviour drives bubbles — and the people who follow the herd the hardest usually exit last, at the lowest price.
  • Anchoring Bias: If you see a kurta marked ₹4,000 slashed to ₹1,800, it feels like a steal. But was it ever worth ₹4,000? You anchored to a number that may have been artificial to begin with. Retailers know this. Deeply.
  • Overconfidence Bias: Studies by Terrance Odean at UC Berkeley found that the more confident individual investors are, the worse their returns tend to be. We consistently overestimate our ability to “beat the market.”
  • Confirmation Bias: You believe Infosys will bounce back, so you only read the articles that agree with you. This isn’t investing — it’s storytelling with your money.
How much more painful a loss feels vs. an equivalent gain (Kahneman & Tversky)
70% Of Indian retail investors exit mutual funds within 2 years, often during downturns (AMFI)
₹83K Cr Worth of SIP investments in India monthly as of late 2024 (AMFI data)

The Spending Psychology: Why Discounts Are a Trap

India runs on sale season. Big Billion Day. End of Season Sale. Diwali offers. And there’s a reason these events generate thousands of crores in revenue in just 48 hours — because the psychology of spending is expertly exploited.

Mental Accounting: Your Brain Keeps Separate Wallets

Here’s something strange about how humans think about money. Economist Richard Thaler (another Nobel laureate) discovered that people mentally categorise money into different “buckets” — salary, bonus, winnings, gifts. And they spend each bucket differently.

That’s why someone who would never spend ₹10,000 from their salary on a dinner might happily do it with a Diwali bonus. It’s the same ₹10,000. But the brain doesn’t treat it the same way.

This also explains why credit cards increase spending. When you tap your card, you’re not spending “your money” in your brain’s accounting system — it’s categorised as future money, which feels less real.

“Money is only a tool. It will take you wherever you wish, but it will not replace you as the driver.” — Ayn Rand

The FOMO Economy

Fear of Missing Out isn’t just a social media problem. It’s an investing problem. When the Sensex is hitting all-time highs and your college WhatsApp group is sharing stock tips, the emotional pressure to participate is real. FOMO pushes people to enter markets at peaks — exactly the wrong time.

According to the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI), a significant portion of new retail investor accounts were opened between 2020 and 2022 — during one of the biggest bull runs in Indian market history. Many of these investors had never seen a serious correction and had no framework to handle one.

The Smart Move

The antidote to FOMO investing is a written investment plan. When you have documented goals — ₹50 lakh for your child’s education in 15 years, ₹1 crore for retirement — random market noise has less power over your decisions. You’re playing a different game than everyone else.


The Investing Mindset: Thinking Long When the World Thinks Short

The single biggest predictor of investment success isn’t intelligence or timing — it’s behaviour under pressure. Morgan Housel’s widely cited book The Psychology of Money makes this case brilliantly: wealth is built not by picking the best stocks, but by avoiding the worst decisions.

In India, the temptation to churn portfolios is enormous. New IPOs. Hot sectors. Neighbour’s tips. But data from SEBI consistently shows that long-term equity mutual fund investors significantly outperform active traders — largely because they do less, not more.

Delayed Gratification: The ₹1 Lakh Lesson

Imagine you invest ₹1 lakh in an index fund at age 25. At 12% annual returns (roughly the historical average of Nifty 50), that single investment becomes approximately ₹93 lakhs by age 65. You did nothing. You just didn’t panic and sell.

Now imagine you pulled it out at age 35 because the market fell 25%. That ₹1 lakh, which had grown to around ₹3 lakh, would have needed decades more to reach the same destination. Patience isn’t passive — it’s one of the highest-return activities in personal finance.

Common Mistake

Trying to time the market is one of the most expensive hobbies an Indian investor can have. A 2023 study by Value Research found that investors who stayed invested in equity mutual funds for 10+ years saw positive returns in nearly 100% of cases, regardless of when they entered.


How to Rewire Your Financial Brain

Understanding the psychology of money is only half the work. The other half is designing systems that work with your brain’s quirks instead of fighting them.

Automate investments first. Set up your SIP to deduct on salary credit day. Your brain never gets attached to money it never sees. This one change alone is responsible for more long-term wealth creation than any stock tip ever given.

Create a 48-hour rule for purchases above ₹5,000. Impulse purchases rely on emotional urgency. Give yourself two days. If you still want it after 48 hours, it’s probably not just an impulse. If you forget about it — you just saved yourself ₹5,000.

Separate your investment account from your spending account. What you can’t easily access, you won’t impulsively spend. This is mental accounting working in your favour.

Limit your financial news consumption. Research by Brad Barber and Terrance Odean shows that the more frequently investors check their portfolios, the worse their long-term performance. Daily checking turns investors into traders. Monthly checking keeps them investors.

Name your financial goals. Accounts named “Anika’s College Fund” or “Retirement at 55” are psychologically harder to raid than accounts named “Savings 2.” It sounds simple. It works remarkably well.


Final Thought: The Richest People Are Boring Investors

The most successful long-term investors are not exciting people. They didn’t buy crypto at the right time. They didn’t short the market in 2020. They just quietly invested in diversified funds every month for 20 years, didn’t panic when the market fell, and let compounding do the heavy lifting.

Understanding the psychology behind investing and spending doesn’t mean you become emotionless. It means you build systems that protect your future self from your present self’s impulses. Because the version of you that wants to buy now and panic-sell later will always exist. The goal is to make it harder for that version to win.

Your money decisions are 80% psychology and 20% math. Master the first, and the second becomes straightforward.

Want More Real Talk on Money?

Join our WhatsApp Channel for honest, jargon-free financial insights made for Indians — no spam, no fake tips.

Follow on WhatsApp

Sources & References

  • Kahneman, D. & Tversky, A. (1979). Prospect Theory. Econometrica. jstor.org
  • Thaler, R. H. (1985). Mental Accounting and Consumer Choice. Marketing Science.
  • Housel, M. (2020). The Psychology of Money. Harriman House.
  • Barber, B. & Odean, T. (2000). Trading Is Hazardous to Your Wealth. Journal of Finance.
  • SEBI Annual Report 2023–24. sebi.gov.in
  • Association of Mutual Funds in India (AMFI). SIP Data 2024. amfiindia.com
  • Value Research. Long-term Equity Fund Performance Study, 2023. valueresearchonline.com

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Disclaimer: The content on investopedia.org.in is educational and not financial advice. Consult a certified financial advisor before investing.
Scroll to Top